Bathtub vs Shower? Right Choice for Your Milwaukee Bathroom

Bathrooms: they’re not just a room in your home, they’re a sanctuary. And in the bustling city of Milwaukee, having a space where you can unwind is almost as essential as a deep-dish pizza. So, when it comes to renovating your bathroom, the bathtub versus shower debate is like choosing between the Cubs and the White Sox – everyone has an opinion, but what works best for you?

The Great Debate: Bathtub or Shower?

The bathtub versus shower debate is more than a choice of fixtures; it’s about how you envision your daily routine and relaxation. Each option offers unique benefits and potential drawbacks, making your decision highly personal and dependent on various factors, including lifestyle, space, and personal preferences.

Pros of a Bathtub

  1. Relaxation and Therapy: Bathtubs offer unparalleled relaxation. The ability to take a long, leisurely bath after a stressful day is priceless. In colder months, a hot bath can be incredibly soothing, providing both physical and mental relaxation. Therapeutic options like whirlpool tubs can also offer hydrotherapy benefits, helping with muscle relaxation and stress relief.
  2. Family-Friendly: For families with young children, a bathtub is almost a necessity. It’s not only easier to bathe children in a tub, but it’s also a space for them to play and enjoy. Bathtime becomes an enjoyable activity rather than a chore, and it can be an essential part of a child’s bedtime routine.
  3. Resale Value: A home with at least one bathtub is often more appealing to potential buyers. This is particularly true in family-oriented neighborhoods or areas where traditional home styles are prevalent. While a stylish shower can be a selling point, the absence of a bathtub can be a deal-breaker for families with young children or people who enjoy baths.

Cons of a Bathtub

  1. Space Requirements: In many Milwaukee homes, space is a premium commodity. Installing a bathtub requires significant space, which can be a major drawback in smaller bathrooms. This is especially challenging in apartments or older homes with limited square footage.
  2. Water Usage and Environmental Concerns: Bathtubs require a significant amount of water to fill, which can lead to higher water bills and more significant environmental impact. For those who are environmentally conscious, this can be a considerable downside.
  3. Accessibility Issues: For the elderly or those with mobility issues, getting in and out of a bathtub can be difficult and potentially hazardous. This is a significant consideration for those planning to age in place or with family members who have mobility challenges.

Pros of a Shower

  1. Space-Saving and Versatility: Showers are ideal for smaller bathrooms common in many Milwaukee homes. They take up less space and can be designed to fit into various layouts, including corners or even under sloped ceilings. A well-designed shower can also make a small bathroom appear larger and more open.
  2. Efficiency and Water Conservation: Showers are generally more water-efficient than baths, especially when equipped with low-flow showerheads. They’re perfect for the fast-paced lifestyle of many Milwaukee residents, offering a quick and efficient way to get ready for the day.
  3. Customization and Modern Amenities: Modern showers can be customized with various features, including multiple showerheads, steam functions, built-in seats, and ambient lighting. These features can transform a simple shower into a luxurious, spa-like experience, offering relaxation and rejuvenation.

Cons of a Shower

  1. Limited Relaxation Options: While a shower can be relaxing, it generally doesn’t offer the same level of leisure and decompression as a long soak in a bathtub. This can be a significant downside for those who view bath time as an essential relaxation and self-care ritual.
  2. Challenges for Families with Young Children: Showering young children can be challenging and less safe compared to a bathtub. It can also be less fun for the kids, as showers don’t offer the same play opportunities as bathtubs.
  3. Resale Value Considerations: Some homebuyers specifically look for a bathtub when purchasing a home. A house without a bathtub might be less appealing to a segment of potential buyers, which could impact the resale value or marketability of your home.

Bathtub vs Shower: The Deciding Factors

When choosing between a bathtub and a shower for your Milwaukee bathroom renovation, several factors should guide your decision:

  1. Space Considerations: The size and layout of your bathroom are perhaps the most significant factors. In smaller bathrooms, a shower might be the only feasible option, while larger spaces can accommodate a bathtub or even a separate tub and shower.
  2. Lifestyle and Daily Routine: Consider your daily routine and preferences. If you rarely take baths and prefer quick showers, a bathtub might not be a necessary investment. Conversely, if you enjoy long, relaxing soaks, a bathtub can be a worthwhile addition to your home.
  3. **Future Plans and ResaleValue**: If you plan to sell your home in the future, think about what might appeal to potential buyers. In some neighborhoods or for certain demographics, having a bathtub could be a crucial selling point.
  4. Budget and Remodeling Costs: Finally, consider your budget. In general, installing a shower can be less expensive than a bathtub, especially if you opt for a high-end tub or additional features like jets or a standalone design. However, prices can vary widely based on the materials, size, and complexity of the installation.

Design and Aesthetics: Making It Work

No matter what you choose, the design and aesthetic of your bathroom should reflect your style and the character of your home. Milwaukee is known for its diverse architecture and design, and your bathroom can be a reflection of this cultural richness.

Personalizing Your Space

  1. Tiles and Textures: Choosing the right tiles and textures can greatly influence the look and feel of your bathroom. Consider using materials that reflect Milwaukee’s architectural heritage, like classic subway tiles or luxurious marble, to add character and elegance to your space.
  2. Fixtures and Features: The fixtures and features you choose, whether for a bathtub or shower, can make a significant difference in both functionality and style. Opt for high-quality fixtures that complement the overall design of your bathroom and enhance the user experience.
  3. Lighting and Accessories: Good lighting is crucial in a bathroom, not just for practicality but also for creating ambiance. Combine different types of lighting, such as overhead lights and wall sconces, to achieve a balanced and inviting space. Don’t forget to accessorize with items that add both function and style, like mirrors, towel racks, and bath mats.

Need Help? Work with Milwaukee Bathroom Remodeling

If you’re looking for a reliable and experienced bathroom remodeling company in Milwaukee, look no further than Milwaukee Bathroom Remodeling. Our team of experts can help you make the right decision between a bathtub and a shower, and provide you with high-quality installation and renovation services. Contact us today to learn more about how we can help you transform your bathroom into a functional and stylish space.


How long does a typical bathroom renovation take in Milwaukee?

A typical bathroom renovation in Milwaukee can take anywhere from a few weeks to several months, depending on the complexity of the project and the scope of work.

Can I install heated floors in my bathroom?

Yes, heated floors are a popular feature in bathroom renovations and can be installed under both tile and stone flooring. They add comfort and luxury, especially during Milwaukee’s colder months.

What are some eco-friendly options for bathroom renovations?

Eco-friendly options for bathroom renovations include low-flow toilets and showerheads, LED lighting, and sustainable materials like bamboo flooring or recycled glass tiles. These choices can help reduce your environmental impact and potentially lower utility bills.


Related Posts